Original ArticleAre there vocal cues to human developmental stability? Relationships between facial fluctuating asymmetry and voice attractiveness
Introduction
Mate choice is predicated, in part, on heritable fitness benefits (Petrie, 1994), and organisms are attentive to biomarkers that putatively indicate whether a potential mate possesses genes that would contribute additively to offspring fitness (Andersson, 1994)—that is, whether a mate is high in genetic quality (Hunt, Bussiere, Jennions, & Brooks, 2004). One such biomarker is fluctuating asymmetry (FA; e.g., Møller, 1992, Swaddle, 1996, Thornhill and Gangestad, 1999a, Van Valen, 1962, Van Valen, 1973). FA is exhibited in bilaterally symmetrical traits if the difference between the left and right sides has a population normal distribution with a mean of zero (Palmer & Strobeck, 1986). Substantial evidence from humans (e.g., Gangestad et al., 1994, Livshits and Kobyliansky, 1991) as well as an array of vertebrates and insects (Parsons, 1990) indicates that the degree to which bilaterally symmetrical traits deviate from perfect symmetry reflects developmental instability resulting from harmful mutations and environmental perturbations. Experimental exposure to common environmental stressors, for example, can increase asymmetry in laboratory rats (e.g., Mooney et al., 1985, Sciulli et al., 1979).
In humans, individuals with known genetic or chromosomal abnormalities have greater dental FA than do controls (e.g., Barden, 1980, Peretz et al., 1988), and FA displays a negative relationship with genetic heterozygosity (Livshits & Kobyliansky, 1991), which can increase fitness by lowering the risk of expressing deleterious recessive alleles and by increasing acquired immunity through the major histocompatibility complex (MHC; reviewed in Kempenaers, 2007). Lower FA in ear height, wrist breadth, and digit length has predicted reduced resting metabolic rate (Manning, Koukourakis & Brodie, 1997) and better mental health (Martin, Manning, & Dowrick, 1999) in men, and lower facial FA shows a similar relationship with perceptions of physical health (Jones et al., 2001). Moreover, FA is positively correlated with female body mass, age, and age at first childbirth, all indications of reduced fecundity (Manning, Scutt, Whitehouse & Leinster, 1997). A recent meta-analysis also found a small negative relationship between FA and general intelligence (Banks, Batchelor, & McDaniel, 2010). Together, these results suggest that bilateral symmetry may reflect the fit between an organism's genotype and environment during development.
As a putative indicator of a genotype's resilience to environmental insults, FA is related to mate choice across a variety of nonhuman species. For example, among field crickets (Gryllus campestris), males successful in obtaining mates display lower FA than do less successful males (Simmons, 1995). Likewise, female zebra finches (Taeniopygia guttata) prefer to be near males wearing symmetrically colored experimental leg bands (Swaddle, 1996).
In humans, several studies have reported significant correlations between FA and perceptions of facial attractiveness (e.g., Abend et al., 2015, Grammer and Thornhill, 1994, Komori et al., 2009, Perrett et al., 1999, Rhodes et al., 2001). In addition, women who view themselves as attractive show a greater preference for symmetry in male faces (Little, Burt, Penton-Voak, & Perrett, 2001), suggesting that symmetrical mates are valued and are more attainable by women of higher mate value. Some studies (e.g., Little and Jones, 2012, Little et al., 2007b), but not others (e.g., Peters, Simmons, & Rhodes, 2009), have found that women in the fertile phase of the ovulatory cycle exhibit a greater preference for symmetrical faces and bodies, again suggesting an association between symmetry and genetic quality, since genetic benefits can be obtained only when conception is possible. There is also evidence that humans mate assortatively for facial symmetry, indicating that symmetry or correlated traits may influence mate choice (Burriss, Roberts, Welling, Puts, & Little, 2011).
While bilateral symmetry appears to be important in predicting mating decisions, preferences for symmetrical mates may not always reflect preferences for symmetry per se. Bilateral symmetry has been found to predict attractiveness even in the absence of visual cues to asymmetry itself, and thus asymmetry must be related to other phenotypic cues. For example, women in the fertile phase of the ovulatory cycle have shown a preference for symmetrical men when exposed exclusively to the men's body odor (Gangestad and Thornhill, 1998, Thornhill and Gangestad, 1999b). Another study found a female preference for low FA in men even when study participants were shown only the left or right half of each male face, preventing them from assessing symmetry directly (Scheib, Gangestad, & Thornhill, 1999).
Developmental stability may also be conveyed vocally. Hughes, Harrison, and Gallup (2002) found both sexes to exhibit a negative relationship between upper limb FA (particularly finger length FA) and attractiveness assessed from vocal stimuli alone. Abend et al. (2015) similarly obtained a negative relationship between women's vocal attractiveness and measures of FA from their upper and lower limbs as well as the head and face. These studies join other research demonstrating the salience of voice as an influence on mate choice in humans (reviewed in Feinberg, 2008, Pisanski and Feinberg, 2013, Puts et al., 2012).
Moreover, vocal and facial attractiveness may covary (e.g., Saxton, Burriss, Murray, Rowland, & Roberts, 2009) in part because both the face and vocal folds are bilaterally symmetrical, and both may therefore reflect deleterious environmental influences during development. For example, asymmetric shape, size, or tension in the vocal folds could result in audible changes in the voice, such as hoarseness (Eysholdt, Rosanowski, & Hoppe, 2003), and indeed, Hughes, Pastizzo, and Gallup (2008) found that limb FA in men predicted a measure of vocal hoarseness. Developmental instability may also affect the size and shape of vocal structures, as well as tension on the vocal folds or the positioning of the larynx in the vocal tract, which would influence vocal pitch and timbre, respectively (for fuller consideration of potential links between FA and vocal attractiveness, please see Discussion).
Some research indicates that women's vocal attractiveness is related to fertility and reproductive potential (Bryant and Haselton, 2009, Pipitone and Gallup, 2008, Pipitone and Gallup, 2011, Puts et al., 2013, Wheatley et al., 2014), though scant research has explored relationships between vocal attractiveness and FA in either sex. To our knowledge, Abend et al. (2015) is the only study conducted to date investigating relationships between vocal attractiveness and facial FA. Furthermore, not all research on FA supports the prediction that individuals will tend to prefer mates lower in FA. For example, some research on humans (e.g., Langlois et al., 1994, Swaddle and Cuthill, 1995), as well as nonhuman species (e.g., Oakes and Barnard, 1994, Tomkins and Simmons, 1998), has failed to show preferences for mates with low FA, while other research has found a statistically significant relationship between FA and attractiveness only in particular situations (Springer et al., 2007).
There are likely several reasons for these discrepancies. First, FA is a weak index of developmental instability, such that associations between FA and measures of mate quality are difficult to detect using modest sample sizes (Van Dongen & Gangestad, 2011). Second, relationships with FA may be complicated by directional asymmetry (DA), which characterizes traits for which the difference between the left and right sides has a population normal distribution with a mean that deviates from zero (Møller, 1994). Directional asymmetry, such as occurs in testes size in many bird species (Møller, 1994) and in the lower limbs of humans (Auerbach & Ruff, 2006), may constitute part of an organism's normal development (Graham et al., 1998, Martin et al., 2008). Since the presence of DA may complicate measures of FA, it is critical to take DA into consideration in research examining FA. While some studies have done so (e.g., Abend et al., 2015, Brown et al., 2008, Manning, 1995), others have not (e.g., Gangestad and Thornhill, 1997, Hughes et al., 2002, Thornhill et al., 1995). Finally, prior research has disproportionately sampled from Western societies, especially individuals of European genetic ancestry. Not only do such individuals differ in facial morphology from those of other populations (Farkas, Katic, & Forrest, 2005), but Westerners may also have greater access to modern medical and cosmetic technologies that can buffer them from environmental stressors, weakening relationships between FA and measures of attractiveness (Apicella, 2011).
In the present paper, we tested whether somatic FA predicts vocal attractiveness by collecting data in three studies that were designed in part to address the limitations of prior research while enabling us to explore the robustness of these relationships across methodologies and populations. We measured FA from the face due to the centrality of facial symmetry in prior work as well as the status of the face as a feature-rich space that is developmentally distinct from the upper limb, measured by Hughes et al. (2002) and the upper and lower limb included in Abend et al. (2015). In Studies 1 and 2, we measured FA from two-dimensional (2D) facial photographs, following most prior studies of facial asymmetry and attractiveness (Jones et al., 2001). Study 1 data were collected from U.S. undergraduate students, whereas Study 2 data were collected from the Hadza, a Tanzanian forager population less protected by modern medicine from environmental insults than are samples drawn from the West. Compared to Western samples, Hadza facial and vocal characteristics should thus more strongly reflect individuals' constitutional resilience to environmental stressors, such as pathogens. Finally, in Study 3, we explored facial FA and vocal attractiveness among U.S. undergraduates using the 2D methods employed in the first two studies as well as three-dimensional (3D) images measured via spatially dense geometric morphometrics, which provides far greater shape information than does 2D imagery (Abend et al., 2015, Brown et al., 2008).
Section snippets
Participants
One hundred twenty-four male (mean age = 20.08 ± 1.76 years) and 201 female (mean age = 19.97 ± 1.55 years) students from Michigan State University participated as part of a larger study of siblings (see, e.g., Puts et al., 2013, Wheatley et al., 2014). If same-sex siblings participated, we randomly selected one from each sibling group (generally pairs). In addition, only students self-identifying as “White” were used, as facial morphology varies by ethnicity (e.g., Farkas et al., 2005), and we did not
Participants
Twenty-eight male (mean age = 29.32 ± 5.84 years) and 39 female (mean age = 29.03 ± 6.37 years) participants were recruited from the approximately 1000 Hadza hunter–gatherers living in remote savannah–woodland habitats of Northern Tanzania. The Hadza have a sexual division of labor in which women collect fruits and nuts and dig for tubers, while men collect honey and hunt animals (Marlowe, 2004). The Hadza are among an increasingly small number of human populations still subsisting by hunting and
Participants
Seventy-nine self-identified White men (mean age = 19.92 ± 1.51) from The Pennsylvania State University participated as part of two broader studies, one on long-term romantic relationships (supplementary online material 2, sample A), the other on interpersonal dynamics (supplementary online material 2, sample B). Data-collection procedures were approved by the University's institutional review board.
Face measurement
Consistent with methods used in Studies 1 and 2, two-dimensional facial photographs were taken using
Meta-analysis
In addition to examining independently the three studies reported here, we meta-analyzed the data across the studies, as well as the results of Hughes et al. (2002) and Abend et al. (2015), to produce summary estimates of the relationship between FA and vocal attractiveness. Effect sizes were obtained for males from all studies reported herein plus Hughes et al. (2002), and for females from Studies 1 and 2 as well as Hughes et al. (2002) and Abend et al. (2015). This resulted in total samples
Discussion
In the present research, we found relationships between vocal attractiveness and fluctuating asymmetry in both sexes. Though analyses should be re-conducted as more data accumulate, our meta-analyses gave point estimates for population correlations between vocal attractiveness and FA of −.23 for men and −.29 for women, using 3D facial FA from Study 3 and Abend et al. (2015). All effect sizes across samples were in the same (negative) direction, although they ranged in magnitude, with greater
Future directions
Future studies should investigate how developmental instability relates to the anatomy of the vocal tract, and which vocal anatomical characteristics and acoustic features of the voice mediate relationships between somatic asymmetry and vocal attractiveness (see, for example, Hughes et al., 2008). While such an exploration is beyond the scope of the present paper, some informed speculation is possible. One possibility is that developmental instability affects vocal attractiveness by influencing
Funding
This work was supported by the National Institutes of Mental Health [grant number T32 MH70343-05], the National Science Foundation [REG grant to C.L.A. and GRFP grant to J.R.W.], and The Pennsylvania State University and Harvard University.
Supplementary materials
The following are the supplementary data to this article.
Acknowledgments
We thank Arslan Zaidi for assistance designing Fig. 3, Tobias Kordsmeyer for insights on measuring facial FA, Matt Winn for input on the Discussion, and Lisa DeBruine and two anonymous reviewers for comments on previous drafts of this manuscript.
References (105)
- et al.
The sound of female shape: a redundant signal of vocal and facial attractiveness
Evolution and Human Behavior
(2015) Sexual selection
(1994)On the universality of attractiveness
- et al.
hunter–gatherer families and parenting
- et al.
Voice pitch alters mate-choice-relevant perception in hunter–gatherers
Proceedings of the Biological Sciences
(2009) - et al.
Limb bone bilateral asymmetry: Variability and commonality among modern humans
Journal of Human Evolution
(2006) - et al.
Smarter people are (a bit) more symmetrical: A meta-analysis of the relationship between intelligence and fluctuating asymmetry
Intelligence
(2010) Fluctuating dental asymmetry: A measure of developmental instability in Down syndrome
American Journal of Physical Anthropology
(1980)- et al.
Comprehensive meta-analysis version 2
(2005) - et al.
Fluctuating asymmetry and preferences for sex-typical bodily characteristics
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America
(2008)
Vocal cues of ovulation in human females
Biology Letters
Heterosexual romantic couples mate assortatively for facial symmetry, but not masculinity
Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin
Integrating face and voice in person perception
Trends in Cognitive Sciences
A robust statistical surface registration framework using implicit function representations—Application in craniofacial reconstruction
Improved facial outcome assessment using a 3D anthropometric mask
International Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery
Sexual dimorphism in multiple aspects of 3D facial symmetry and asymmetry defined by spatially dense geometric morphometrics
Journal of Anatomy
Spatially-dense 3D facial asymmetry assessment in both typical and disordered growth
Journal of Anatomy
Developmental stability and fitness: The evidence is not quite so clear
The American Naturalist
Vocal and visual attractiveness are related in women
Animal Behaviour
Generalization and the evolution of symmetry preferences
Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B: Biological Sciences
Vocal fold vibration irregularities caused by different types of laryngeal asymmetry
European Archives of Oto-Rhino-Laryngology
Voice and articulation handbook
International anthropometric study of facial morphology in various ethnic groups/races
Journal of Craniofacial Surgery
Are human faces and voices ornaments signaling common underlying cues to mate value?
Evolutionary Anthropology: Issues, News, and Reviews
The voice and face of woman: One ornament that signals quality?
Evolution and Human Behavior
The evolution of human mating: Trade-offs and strategic pluralism
Behavioral and Brain Sciences
The evolutionary psychology of extrapair sex: The role of fluctuating asymmetry
Evolution and Human Behavior
Menstrual cycle variation in women's preferences for the scent of symmetrical men
Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B: Biological Sciences
Human sexual selection and developmental stability
Facial attractiveness, developmental stability, and fluctuating asymmetry
Ethology and Sociobiology
Directional asymmetry and the measurement of developmental instability
Biological Journal of the Linnean Society
Human (Homo sapiens) facial attractiveness and sexual selection: The role of symmetry and averageness
Journal of Comparative Psychology
Statistical models for meta-analysis
The power of statistical tests in meta-analysis
Psychological Methods
Measuring inconsistency in meta-analyses
BMJ: British Medical Journal
Asymmetry of the laryngeal framework: A morphologic study of cadaver larynges
Annals of Otology, Rhinology & Laryngology
The sound of symmetry: Voice as a marker of developmental instability
Evolution and Human Behavior
The sound of symmetry revisited: Subjective and objective analyses of voice
Journal of Nonverbal Behavior
What is genetic quality?
Trends in Ecology & Evolution
The role of symmetry in attraction to average faces
Perception & Psychophysics
Facial symmetry and judgements of apparent health: Support for a “good genes” explanation of the attractiveness–symmetry relationship
Evolution and Human Behavior
Mate choice and genetic quality: A review of the heterozygosity theory
Advances in the Study of Behavior
Evolution, traits, and the stages of human courtship: Qualifying the parental investment model
Journal of Personality
Secular trends in craniofacial asymmetry studied by geometric morphometry and generalized Procrustes methods
Geometric morphometrics of developmental instability: Analyzing patterns of fluctuating asymmetry with Procrustes methods
Evolution
Shape analysis of symmetric structures: Quantifying variation among individuals and asymmetry
Evolution
Averageness or symmetry: Which is more important for facial attractiveness?
Acta Psychologica
Relating visual and vocal attractiveness for moving and static faces
Animal Behaviour
What is average and what is not average about attractive faces?
Psychological Science
Is developmental stability heritable?
Journal of Evolutionary Biology
Evidence against perceptual bias views for symmetry preferences in human faces
Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences
Cited by (52)
Can listeners assess men's self-reported health from their voice?
2021, Evolution and Human BehaviorCitation Excerpt :In line with the stress-linked ICHH (Rantala et al., 2012), recent research has shown that men with relatively high levels of T and low levels of cortisol have lower fo (Puts et al., 2016). Vocal attractiveness ratings (which are correlated with masculinity and T; Cartei et al., 2014; Feinberg et al., 2005) have been found to be associated with lower levels of facial fluctuating asymmetry, a putative indicator of developmental instability (Hill et al., 2017; but see Kordsmeyer et al., 2020). Furthermore, the increase in men's fo with aging occurs with a concomitant decrease in circulating T levels and an increase in frailty (Hyde et al., 2010; Stathopoulos et al., 2011).
Dominance of face over voice in human attractiveness judgments: ERP evidence
2023, PsychophysiologyA Preliminary Investigation Into Individual Differences that Predict Men’s Preferences for Cues to Fertility in Women’s Faces
2023, Adaptive Human Behavior and PhysiologyWomen misjudge men’s physical characteristics based on vocal cues
2023, BioacousticsDesign of Voice Recognition Acoustic Compression System Based on Neural Network
2022, Wireless Personal CommunicationsDevelopmental instability, fluctuating asymmetry, and human psychological science
2022, Emerging Topics in Life Sciences
- 1
Present address: Department of Anthropology, University of Washington, Seattle, WA 98195, USA.
- 2
Present address: Department of Psychology, Oakland University, Rochester, MI 48309, USA.
- 3
Present address: Department of Psychology, University of Basel, Basel, Switzerland.