Original ArticleIs obesity un-American? Disease concerns bias implicit perceptions of national identity
Introduction
Approximately two-thirds of the United States population is overweight or obese (Flegal, Carroll, Ogden, & Curtin, 2010), and this fact appears not to have escaped the public's attention, as indicated by the increasing popularity of reality television shows such as The Biggest Loser, More to Love, and Fat Actress. Such trends thus provoke the question—is it that to be American is to be obese?
The current research proposes that, despite the increasing prevalence of obesity in American society, Americans nonetheless exclude obese individuals from their implicit national identity. Social cognition is guided in part by fundamental motives designed to help people overcome challenges recurrently faced throughout evolutionary history (Kenrick, Neuberg, Griskevicius, Becker, & Schaller, 2010), including the recurrent adaptive challenge of avoiding contagious diseases. A fundamental motivation for disease avoidance may promote the implicit exclusion of obese individuals from one's national identity.
People tend to include and exclude specific subgroups from their mental representation of the superordinate group (Devos and Banaji, 2005, Devos et al., 2010, Devos and Ma, 2008). An evolutionary perspective provides a useful framework for understanding why certain subgroups of individuals may be included or excluded from a superordinate group identity. Throughout history, other people have afforded both opportunities and threats relevant to fundamental survival and reproduction-relevant social goals (Neuberg & Cottrell, 2008). For example, contact with other people can provide opportunities for building prosocial alliances. However, it can also threaten fundamental goals related to survival (e.g., people are a common source of physical violence and communicable diseases). Consequently, many psychological processes are sensitive to characteristics of others that imply potential opportunities or threats (Maner, Miller, Moss, Leo, & Plant, 2012). The ascription of group identity may be one such psychological process. When forming mental representations of their group, people may include others who offer beneficial opportunities (thereby increasing the probability of interacting with those others) and exclude others who represent costly threats (thus promoting avoidance of those threats). Contagious disease may be one threat that shapes the ascription of group identity in this way.
The contraction of a communicable disease often requires close contact with pathogen carriers. Evolutionary perspectives suggest that, as a consequence, people are equipped with a psychological system designed to promote the avoidance of potential pathogen carriers—a sort of behavioral immune system (Neuberg et al., 2011, Schaller and Park, 2011). Indeed, when pathogen concerns are made salient, people respond to the presence of heuristic disease cues with a range of affective, cognitive, and behavioral reactions that promote a distancing of oneself from potential sources of disease (Ackerman et al., 2009, Curtis et al., 2004, Miller and Maner, 2011, Miller and Maner, 2012, Schaller and Duncan, 2007).
People may attempt to avoid pathogen carriers via social exclusion and avoidance of groups heuristically associated with disease (Navarrete and Fessler, 2006, Navarrete et al., 2007).
Of particular relevance to this study, implicit exclusion of a subgroup from the mental representation of a superordinate group has downstream effects on actual discriminatory and avoidant attitudes toward members of that subgroup (Yogeeswaran & Dasgupta, 2010). Thus, implicitly categorizing a subgroup of people heuristically perceived as a pathogen threat as an unfamiliar outgroup may promote behavioral avoidance, exclusion, or stigmatization. This behavioral avoidance, could, in turn lead to less risk of fitness-reducing disease contraction. Thus, people's mental representations of shared group membership can have actual consequences for behavior and fitness.
Pathogens themselves are invisible to the naked eye, yet they often produce visible morphological irregularities. Thus, many morphological irregularities can serve as heuristic cues of underlying pathogenic infection. Because obese individuals display morphological abnormalities (e.g., a highly exaggerated midsection), they may be (mis)perceived as pathogen carriers (Crandall et al., 2009, Harvey et al., 2002, Lieberman et al., 2012, Miller and Maner, 2012, Neel et al., 2013, Park et al., 2007, Park et al., 2013). Consistent with this perspective, adults (Lieberman et al., 2012, Oaten et al., 2009), and young children (Klaczynski, 2008) display disgust reactions toward the obese. When primed with disease concerns, people also display a range of processes that facilitate the avoidance of, or prejudice toward, obese others (e.g., Miller and Maner, 2012, Park and Isherwood, 2011, Park et al., 2007). Moreover, although anti-fat prejudice is observed among both thin and obese observers, thin individuals—individuals that likely view obesity as a more substantially atypical morphology—exhibit a greater degree of prejudice (Schwartz, Vartanian, Nosek, & Brownell, 2006).
We tested three primary hypotheses:
- 1.
Because obesity is a heuristic cue to disease, we predicted that obese individuals would be excluded from people's implicit representations of superordinate group identity.
- 2.
This effect would be apparent primarily among thin participants, for whom obesity is especially morphologically atypical.
- 3.
The effect among thin participants would be exacerbated when disease concerns are especially salient.
In two studies, we tested these three hypotheses by examining whether Americans implicitly exclude obese individuals from their national identity. In Study 1, we manipulated disease concerns via experimental priming methodology. In Study 2, we capitalized on natural variation in the salience of disease caused by recent illness.
Section snippets
Study 1: Situational concerns about disease, obesity, and implicit national identity
In Study 1, we experimentally primed American participants with either disease-connoting images or control images before they completed an implicit measure of the degree to which they associated obesity with the American identity. Participants also indicated their perceived relative weight (compared to the average person) and actual weight. We hypothesized that American participants, particularly thin Americans, would be more likely to implicitly exclude obesity from their national identity
Study 2: Ecological disease concerns, obesity, and implicit national identity
Being recently ill can lead to activation of the behavioral immune system (Miller & Maner, 2011). Therefore, in Study 2 we examined whether recent illness promotes the implicit exclusion of obesity from the American identity. Akin to Study 1, we hypothesized that thin participants (but not heavier participants) who had been recently ill would implicitly exclude obesity from the American identity to a greater degree than participants who had not recently been ill.
General discussion
An emerging literature indicates that people choose to include and exclude certain groups from their superordinate group identity. While prior research has typically focused on the exclusion of ethnic minorities (Devos and Banaji, 2005, Devos and Ma, 2008), the current research demonstrates that obese people are also implicitly excluded from the American identity. Moreover, the current research provides insight into the factors shaping this biased ascription of group identity. Across two
Supplementary Materials
Supplementary data to this article can be found online at http://beliefandmoralitylab.com/supplementary-data/.
Acknowledgments
The authors thank Will M. Gervais, as well as two anonymous reviewers for critical feedback on the manuscript.
References (41)
- et al.
A pox on the mind: Disjunction of attention and memory in the processing of physical disfigurement
Journal of Experimental Social Psychology
(2009) There's something about obesity: Culture, contagion, rationality, and children's responses to drinks “created” by obese children
Journal of Experimental Child Psychology
(2008)- et al.
Detecting outliers: Do not use standard deviation around the mean, use absolute deviation around the median
Journal of Experimental Social Psychology
(2013) - et al.
Disease avoidance and ethnocentrism: the effects of disease vulnerability and disgust sensitivity on intergroup attitudes
Evolution and Human Behavior
(2006) - et al.
Elevated ethnocentrism in the first trimester of pregnancy
Evolution and Human Behavior
(2007) - et al.
Human threat management systems: Self-protection and disease avoidance
Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews
(2011) - et al.
Pathogen-avoidance mechanisms and the stigmatization of obese people
Evolution and Human Behavior
(2007) Self-reported weight and height
The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition
(1990)- et al.
Multiple regression: Testing and interpreting interactions
(1991) The stigma of overweight in everyday life
Anti-fat prejudice
Evidence that disgust evolved to protect from risk of disease
Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series B: Biological Sciences
American = white?
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
Say “adios” to the American dream? The interplay between ethnic and national identity among Latino and Caucasian Americans
Cultural Diversity and Ethnic Minority Psychology
Is Kate Winslet more American than Lucy Liu? The impact of construal processes on the implicit ascription of a national identity
British Journal of Social Psychology
Evolved disease-avoidance mechanisms and contemporary xenophobic attitudes
Group Processes and Intergroup Behavior
Prevalence and trends in obesity among us adults, 1999–2008
JAMA
Understanding and using the implicit association test: I. An improved scoring algorithm
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
Fear, disgust, and abnormal eating attitudes: A preliminary study
International Journal of Eating Disorders
Mechanisms of bacterial superinfections in viral pneumonias
Schweizerische Medizinische Wochenschrift
Cited by (18)
Functional Heuristics of Disease Transmission from Physical Deformities in Food Preferences
2023, Evolutionary Psychological SciencePathogen disgust is associated with interpersonal bias among healthcare professionals
2023, Evolution, Medicine and Public HealthThe Effect of Infectious Disease Threat on Malevolent Creativity
2022, Journal of IntelligenceThe Behavioral Immune System and Intergroup Bias: Evidence for Asian-Specific Bias at the Onset of the COVID-19 Pandemic
2022, Evolutionary Psychological ScienceDoes Pathogen Avoidance Affect Intergroup Categorization? Replication of Makhanova, Miller, and Maner (2015)
2021, Evolutionary Behavioral Sciences